Could Varroa Resistant "California Bees" Hold Key To Solving The Problem?
Buzzing with intrigue, this episode of Bee Love Beekeeping kicks off with spider venom playing mite assassin.
Then the real fun begins: UC Riverside's Genesis Chong and Owen Wagner dish on their scrappy "Californian" hybrid bees, tough, hybridized survivors that shrug off Varroa infestations that would tank a typical commercial colony.
_____________
$10 off your next order! https://www.mannlakeltd.com/
• Discount Code: MLBEELOVE10
_________________
For beekeepers tired of chemical treatments, this is the kind of hopeful buzz worth tuning in for.
Turns out the secret isn't new chemical treatments — it's happening deep in the brood chamber, where mites mysteriously struggle to reproduce on these bees' larvae.
Scent? Bad nutrition? Chemical trickery? The scientists are still chasing the answer, framing it as an evolutionary tug-of-war between bees and mites.
Toss in a hilarious military-runway bee rescue story, some reflections on falling in love with bees, and you've got a genuinely entertaining, hope-filled episode for anyone invested in the future of beekeeping.
Special thanks to our presenting sponsor, Mann Lake! https://www.mannlakeltd.com/
Mann Lake discount code: MLBEELOVE10 for $10 off your next order.
Follow Us: https://www.beelovebeekeeping.com/follow/
https://www.beelovebeekeeping.com/
Genesis & Owen: https://ciber.ucr.edu/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ciber_ucr/
Facebook: Center for Integrative Bee Research (CIBER)
0:00 in a world brimming with complexity few creatures embody harmony like the honeybee with tireless precision she dances from bloom to bloom each motion guided by millennia upon millennia of instinct each act in service to the whole and then There are the beekeepers, watchful stewards of this ancient symbiosis. Part agriscientist, part poet, they move along their hives with the efficiency of mow, levy and curly, tending to the bees' needs as best they can comprehend, and with the infrequency of a waterfall in the Sahara, sometimes running off flapping and flailing like a penguin on a hot sidewalk. This is their journey. Welcome, welcome to Be Love Beekeeping presented by our great friends and partners in beekeeping. Man Lake. Here's the question of the day. Have we found a solution to varroa mites?
1:34 Can we see it in the near future? Today's interview features researchers from the University of California Riverside who have been studying a possible answer and spoiler alert it's not a new treatment it's genetics. I think you'll find it super interesting but first and not to get confused with my previous statement Here's a story fresh out of Australia about what they're working on to knock down the mites. According to a study led by the University of the Sunshine Coast, researchers have identified components in the venoms of the Tasmanian cave spider and the giant Japanese funnel web spider that killed Varroa without harming the bees.
2:20 Lead author, associate professor Volker Herzig said, we screened 50 venoms mostly from spiders and scorpions by applying them externally to the mites. We found more than 75 % killed the mites within 24 hours. We selected two of the most potent spider venoms for further analysis. We isolated a specific component called a peptide from each of these two venoms and applied them to the bodies of The peptides killed only the mites while the bees survived. These peptides are fully biodegradable and our findings suggest they could be developed into a commercial sustainable treatment for varroa mite infestation in honey bees. The study also includes collaborators from the University of Queensland, the University of Oslo, Ghent University in Belgium, and the Swiss Bee Research Center Agroscope in Switzerland.
3:20 The next steps would include testing the two peptides by applying them in mite -infested beehives to assess how well they work under real -world conditions. There's hope coming from all kinds of directions, so stay tuned. I'd like to welcome two really fun guests to the show today. We've got Genesis Chong and Owen Wagner coming to us from UC Riverside. How are you guys this afternoon? Hi, Eric. Thank you for the invitation. It's really, really nice. The weather, it's getting very warm in here, but it's kind of funky. Last week was cold and this week it's warm again.
4:07 I don't think your cold is the same as the cold where I live. I've been to Riverside. Does that mean it was like only 75 in the afternoon or something? Pretty much. But it gets really windy and bees don't like it that much. There's a good place to jump in. Why don't bees like wind? Usually, I mean this is anecdotally, I like to have the hive entrances facing away from where like the direction of prevailing wind is, because if that comes into the hive entrance, that draft is going to chill the brood. It makes it hard for them to, you know, maintain homostasis within the colony, so. You know, I've never seen a study on this and you guys are the smart ones. You know, you're at the university, so I'm going to ask you this question. I expect a good answer.
4:51 Okay, here we go. And that is... up to about what wind velocity can bees fly? Because if it's too hard of a wind, they just can't. I have no idea. I actually don't know off the top of my head either. All right. Topic for your next PhD. To Google it, yeah. But that's a very interesting question. I never thought about it. Today we're going to be talking about the research that's happening out there at UC Riverside. All about Varroa, Can I call them Varroa resistant bees? Is that going too far? Yes and no because I do agree with you that they do show certain like phenotypic evidence that they are resistant however we still haven't like figured it out. the mechanisms, like, okay, what's making them resistant towards demise? Like, why they have, like, mind levels under the threshold and why they don't get that affected as other stuff of colonies, like honeybees?
6:05 But so far, they have been showing, like, a certain type of resistance that we still don't... are not completely sure how does that work, like... Yeah, we have some hints and with that study we got directions on where to follow up with that. Okay, well time out, we're getting just a little bit ahead of ourselves. I think it would make sense to give us just an overall summary. of what the research was without using too technical of terms, okay? Okay. So just an overall summary, here's what we did, here's what we're trying to find out, and here's some of the things we've learned so far. I'm the apiary manager, so I was working in the field with these research hives, but conclusions for the project, it's here. Basically, how it started, it was that we keep cyber, that it's part of my lab, we keep a very close relationship. with the beekeeping clubs. And from beekeepers, we kept hearing that, oh yeah, feral bees, somehow they show a different behavior towards the mites that they don't need to treat them as often. Their colonies, sometimes they don't get that harm by the mites. So we also, in our APIRE, we do evaluations regularly.
7:35 every three weeks so then we can have like an overview of the colonies and what was surprisingly is that in terms of four years we were like analyzing the data that we took from the evaluations and we found that there was a trend. We call it Californian bees because of the beekeepers like that's why they have like these Californian bees because feral sometimes can sound kind of like these are Africanized bees, which they are, but they are hybrids. They have a certain Africanization degree. And if we compare that with the ones from Central America, Mexico or South America, they do have like a smaller Africanization degree.
8:26 Just jumping in for a second to I think an important distinction to make. when we're talking about the language that we use with these types of bees and moving away from feral, is that we're seeing a lot of beekeepers. I mean, we also work with these bees in a managed environment. So there's like a certain process of re -domestication that's occurred. Like these bees are not feral. We are keeping them long -term in Langstroth hives, multi -generational colonies in the field that we have tight data. that we've been tracking and recording for upwards of like five to six years. So let me make sure that I understand that then. And maybe we just don't have the right terminology, but you're talking about bees that are not straight Italian or straight Carniolan or something like that. You've got bees that are, quote, Californian bees. And probably you could narrow that down to Southern California, I would think. And they have genetics from Africanized bees. I assume Italians may be some feral of some other things. In other words, they've hybridized themselves over time. And bees can do that pretty fast. Yeah, and that's the beautiful part of these because... California it's a hub for the pollination and for the almond pollination they get how many colonies they get like more or less I don't know the exact count but I mean it's one of the largest pollination events in North
9:56 America I think it's one of the largest pollination events in the whole world two million colonies roughly it's huge yeah and the bees that get sent to almond pollination those are commercial stocks that have been like purchased for like from a breeder and these breeder usually they terms to like narrow down like traits like honey production, behavior of the colony and just like performance in general. So those are like the like the genotype or like the stock that is surrounding that area. So that always get to mate with different colonies around. So that creates a type of hybridization.
10:48 So when we are looking at the ancestry of these bees, perhaps, like, okay, what lines does these bees have in them? We can find a type of European ancestry, Middle East ancestry. So they tend to be very diverse. But we think that that's because of the environment that it's around that beekeepers keep having this stock of commercially colonies from breeders that in some way keep this diversity on deferral colonies that then we keep in our PREs. I don't know if you... So for your control groups, you had these, quote, California bees. And then you must have had some other bees that were non -California bees. What's the terminology we're using for those? Well, for those ones we were using just like commercial colonies, colonies that we got from breeders.
11:48 And then we keep them in a common apiary. So they have like in a common garden. Usually when we do, well not usually, when we do like experiments and projects, all the colonies are in the same place. So then they get the same resources around, same environment. And basically, what we were comparing was the number of mice that these colonies were having. in a period of four years. At the end were like 236 colonies I believe but that total of colonies was the total colonies that were among like those four years. Some of them died, we got new ones, some of them did survive like longer and they were able to be like multiple generations but we didn't add like that detailed information into the article because for us what we were interested in was okay let's see the number of demise that they have and let's see how often we were treating these two groups because we were treating these groups we don't have like an actual like like survival in reflected in in the article because then yeah. So what did you find about these California bees? How did they deal with mites better or worse than your
13:21 control group of bees? They manage it spectacularly. If you have a commercial colony, right, and you don't treat for Varroa, I would expect like that colony to not make it to the end of the year. If you establish it as like a package at the beginning of the season, like in spring, even by, I mean, by summer, you're going to see the mite level skyrocket. And then by fall, you're going to see the population of the bees plummet. A lot of that is, you know, expressed through like deformed wing virus, which we almost never see in like this California group that we were examining in the project. And you also just don't see that type of colony collapse. You can have very large hives. I'm talking like two to three deep boxes full of bees going into like late fall and winter at that zero treatment. And you're not seeing really any negative effects. that we associate with like a high Varroa presence in the colony. I think the question I have then is, are they dealing with Varroa better or do they have less Varroa? That's a good question because we needed, we kind of like start from the baseline, just like finding or proving the difference that beekeepers have been seeing the field, like observations that we have seen the field. So we kind of tried to test it so in that article we don't have any mechanism like okay the colonies do this and this is why they are able to survive better however from the field
14:51 we got okay californian colonies they tend to to be barely treated against the mines and often they do keep the noceman counts under the threshold There are some experiments that has been done here in the lab and in San Diego where they have found no relationship with hygienic behavior. So that was kind of another direction that we took. Okay, if there is no huge difference in hygienic behavior, what's going on? Why they are keeping their mind levels on their threshold?
15:31 So what we did was we were comparing larvae from these two stocks, and then we were using some plates as observational arena. In the first part, we used four different ages. from those larvae brought from the two different stocks and they were in the same plate. And in the middle of that plate what we did was we put some mites in the middle, we released them at the same time and then we record that for two hours. and every 15 minutes we will quantify or we will see like okay if a mite was in the area of one stock or the other one a mite in the area of a specific age which was very similar or the same as what we know in the literature that the mites larvae around six to seven days old before they get capped. So then they can go into the root cell and hide on the bottom of that cell until that larvae get capped and start the pupation process where the mite will feed from that larvae and will start their reproductive cycle. It will start laying eggs. Let me just make sure I understand.
16:52 It looks like the difference in the two kinds of bees. is happening in the larval stage of the bees and is it that the Varroa is not as interested in the larva of the California bees or is it some other mechanism? From that experiment we found that the mites seem to be less attractive to the Californian larvae because the reproductive cycle for the mite is so important so finding the perfect holes or the perfect like larvae for them to reproduce it's a moss that they need to do it right and how they they communicate like with chemical communication and stuff so from those findings we go like different directions that we were able to explore quick break to discuss what just might be on your mind right now come on admit it you're imagining the upcoming honey harvest because no matter where you live in the world it's either here now or it will be in the near future and Man Lake is making it so easy to plan for click on over to Man Lake's website for an amazing selection of extractors filters bottling supplies uncapping knives supplies for a comb honey everything and I mean everything you'll need. But if you aren't there quite yet and the honey flows right around the corner, make sure you have extra supers on hand. You
18:23 never can have too many or be too prepared. And right now Man Lake is offering podcast listeners $10 off your next order. Just enter code MLBlove10 at checkout. That's manlakeltd .com. Discount code MLBlove10. Perhaps it could be the larvae emit a different smell when it see it feel like the presence of the mites or Maybe the mites like them less because when they eat from them They don't get like the nutrients that they need to to lay eggs or all these type of theories, but What we did was we did an experiment where we had eight colonies from commercial and eight colonies from Californian ones. And what we did was from deep established colonies. We did splits and put them into nukes and then they all start with the same... We tried to make them start with the same amount of workers, brood frames, food frames from the colony and with queens.
19:35 And then they all start from the same baseline. And then from then we didn't treat them, we didn't give them any supplement or anything. Those colonies already came with their baseline of demise. Since we didn't treat them or anything, and because they were splits, they were just carrying the mites that they were having in their dips. We evaluated them for a period of four months. After that, we had infestation day, where we collected mites from sugar shakes rolls, and then we took 100 mites and we randomly assigned to four of the eight colonies, the mites, and the other four were kind of controls because we wanted to hammer colonies to see what happened if I have like these two groups of colonies and then I'm inducing a high infestation of mites plus the mites that they already are dealing with.
20:36 What will happen for us will be okay. Colonies will collapse because they also were in nukes so they have like less phase. What we found was really interesting because after that induction of infestation, we were like, besides like the evaluations, we were inspecting root frames and we were opening cells with pupae that are dark eye. So by that time, the mite already have offspring within the cell and we were quantifying some mother mite, it got reproduction because have like offspring, it does have a male or oh, there is a mother mite and the pupa it's dark eye and she doesn't have offsprings. Yeah, we're still working on that article that's coming but it's really interesting because So far we found out there is something going on between the brute and the might that somehow the might sometimes it's not able to reproduce. Genesis, why do you think this is? That's a really interesting question because after that... we were looking into the larvae B blood we were looking into the hemolymph to try to see okay if there is maybe when they are in the in the presence of the mind will they kind of release component in their body that
22:08 then when the mind bite will make them not able to reproduce but at the same time we were also trying to get the chemical communication of of those larvae in the present of the mind and without minds and we still are mastering that out to see okay maybe when they are in the present of the mind they do release like different chemical components that make them less attractive or something like that Owen two sentences Why do we think that it's different for these California bees? Bottom line answer, based off of the data that we are looking at, that we're seeing, right?
22:52 We know quantifiably that the mites are experiencing much lower rates of reproductive success in these California hives compared to their commercial counterparts. And that that is all happening in the brood chamber. When we look at like the lab work that we did in the past with like the choice selection with the different larva and then just understanding like the mite reproductive cycle. There is a critical component that is happening in secret, in a sense, encapsulated away in the brew chamber and like really what is going on there we do not have a definitive answer for at the moment. We needed to even just get to this point. We started with that question of like, why are we just seeing this might resistance in this population right and we need to also quantify like are we actually seeing that or are we just looking for an exciting story. And you know that's years of collecting that field data and then be okay no with this this is this is quantifiable this is real and then just working from there. It's been really exciting it's been it's been a journey for sure and i think we're really on like the cusp of i think being able to figure it out too. It is. It's super cool.
24:06 And this is why I'm not a researcher, because I'm way too impatient. So I'm like, let's get to it here. So the cool thing is you've figured out where it's happening. It's in the brood chamber. And now it's a matter of why. Is it a pheromone smell? Is it, I don't know, do they taste bad? They don't have the same kind of nutrition that those commercial colonies did. It's got to be something along those lines. Once that kind of thing is figured out, then maybe something can be taken. Let's say it is a smell, that for some reason Varroa doesn't like the smell of these California bees. Okay, how do we get that smell and reproduce it and put it in hives all over the country? Or is it something else? And that's really cool, the thought that that could actually be something leading us in that direction. and I know that's jumping way too far ahead for this kind of conversation, but as beekeepers who are dealing with Varroa every day and can't stand it, and a lot of us that don't like to put chemicals in our hives if we can help it, but we have to, it'd be so cool to find some other way of dealing with this, whether it's genetic or a smell or whatever the heck it is. i don't know it would be unfair of me to ask you to speculate i already have but where do you think this is going to go from here well that's a good question because like that research i was doing it for my phd
25:37 and i remember that for my qualifying exam one professor asked me how do you see the varroa my problem in five years and i grow like oh i will figure it out I will solve that problem so in five years I don't think that there will be a problem. At the end I ended up with more questions than answers so I think that's something very beautiful about like research and science because we start like from a broader context of an observation as Owen was saying but then slowly we were kind of like narrowing down, depending on the results that we were getting, giving us that direction where to follow. So, oh my God, sorry, I forgot the question. What was the question?
26:23 Can I hold you to your five -year timeline? You're going to have this whole thing solved in five years? Yeah. You can go to a B convention at that point and people will put you up on their shoulders and carry you around. Yeah, but well. And Owen will be throwing rose petals in front of the whole group. What do you think, Owen? Where's this all going? I mean, obviously it has really far reaching practical applications. If we can really crack the code to like, what is this like defense mechanism that these California bees are employing? And especially if it can be replicated. Varroa is not the only stressor that bees are experiencing. But it's like if we could remove that from the equation, it would be huge for the industry as a whole, globally.
27:12 Yeah, it's not the only stressor, but it's really the biggest one right now. Yeah, there are plenty of others and some of the others are there because of ROA. A lot of the diseases are passed around or the bees are weakened because of it or in a place like where I live where in the winter there's going to be three feet of snow on the ground and we're going to have below zero temperatures. If the bees are weakened, whether it is from a disease or varroa or something else, that's the kind of stressor that means they're not going to make it through winter. Okay, on a little bit different note here, I've interviewed some other beekeepers from Southern California that have told me in their opinion all of the bee colonies in Southern California have Africanized genetics. Okay, they're hotter than bee colonies from other places in the country. That's probably why they assume that. They're also telling me things like, hey, it seems like the hottest colonies do the best controlling Varroa. Have you seen any kind of link between behavior and this resistance that you've seen in your research? Not necessarily like directly because we tend to requeen or in a certain way to get rid of those very spicy and hot colonies because it's a liability to have like that in where we keep our colonies
28:42 because there there is like people working on citruses, chickens and stuff so we don't want to have any incidents of these things and also I'm aware that some or mostly the majority of beekeepers that keep them in their back jar or stuff, they also do like a type of filter. So what is really interesting, these colonies give a type of hope to kind of like to the problem. And we know that there are multiple populations around the world that has in a certain way it has built either resistance or tolerance towards the might. It's interesting how nature in a certain way after a while of these two, like the bee and the might, by just being together, how nature in a way fa - not favorite, but it's kind of like it's starting to build that ancestry. It sounds like the direction you were going is saying that it's very likely that if humans were out of the picture, natural selection in these bees would eventually fix this problem anyway. Do you think that's the case? In a way, yeah, it's kind of like nature has figured out something how to deal with the stressor, but at the same time, I know that the mind won't stay behind.
30:15 at some point also might figure out that the new way of the bees to be resistant and then there will be like that fallback. So there is this interesting theory in ecology that it's called Red Queen. That it's when in this case the bee and the mite running after each other and they don't don't catch it but it's kind of this loop when one upgrade and become more resistant than the other one, find ways to overcome that and it's like this constant loop. But it's really interesting because this, the Californian colonies that we have, it's also shaped by nature. It's kind of like all these dogs that beekeepers have around and the deferral ones that have been here, they have been just like breeding among each other and then they have like this diversity in their ancestry. I do think that diversity it's a type of key because give them more tools to use in a way. And then it's just an evolutionary race of who can evolve faster, the bees or the mites. Yeah. Until the next dresser comes along.
31:33 Okay, we're running out of time. There's one thing on the show that I give every guest an opportunity to talk about for a second. And that is the most wild and crazy beekeeping story that you've ever had. And that can be anything from just really unusual behavior in the bees to something embarrassing or painful, you get the idea. And I have a feeling, Owen, because you've been doing this longer and your hands are in the bees more than Genesis's are. Owen, I'm going to give you a second. If you can think of one or two, I'd love you to share one. I guess my favorite bee story that I like to kind of pull out of my back pocket and share with people is like, I guess, a little bit unique based off where we are. We have the March Air Reserve Base over in Moreno Valley. So it's just like a quick city away.
32:26 They have some civilian scientists on base that are doing natural science work and they reached out to me to help facilitate colony removals on the base. They didn't want to just be spraying a bunch of poison around, which I thought was great. I would have really never thought that that was something they would have been that invested in. Yeah. Well, it's also illegal in California. Yeah. Yeah. But I got a call from them one pretty early in the day and they were like this is super urgent. We know that you're really busy doing your research on campus but if you could come out today we have a swarm that moved into a plane out on like the runway and it was slated like it needed to take off for some like important training. like a fighter jet or something. Yeah. And they already had like all of their technician crews out there, but they were all too afraid. There was so many bees flying around. No one wanted to chance getting stung. So I was like, okay, I can clear my schedule.
33:23 I can come out there. And I brought one of the grad students with me at the time. And we got out there and went through a bunch of security and checks to be able to even just get out onto the runway. And then they stopped us and they were like, okay, well now you need to go and pick out from the tread of like the the work trucks tires every piece of gravel we have a lot of gravel down in the field because if any of the gravel gets out onto the tarmac that can really mess up and damage the the wheels of the planes so we had to spend i was just on my back like just digging out all of the gravel that had gotten stuck we finally get out there i don't think they really knew what constituted a big swarm It was, it was very small, like a few hundred bees. So it just brushed them off. I sprayed a little bit of soapy water around where the bees were. I told them, oh, it'll help wash away the smell. So they shouldn't come back and trouble you at all again. And that was it. It was so, so quick and short, but they had built it up.
34:23 Like this was some like major critical issue. Like there were thousands and thousands of bees, but I was like to show that one. like national security is at risk here and you have these men that have been through boot camp and been to war and all kinds of stuff and come get our bees they're scary i love it i love it is there a part two to that i mean i've done some really fun work over there there was another hive that had gotten up into the palm tree i mean i was like a serious colony there was a lot of comb and they brought out a really nice ladder and I had I had to scale all the way up to the top and just like cut it down. I made a little pulley system with some rope and a bucket so I could lower down each section to the ground. I really enjoy doing colony removals when I have the time to. I don't have that much time at the moment anymore just because the research is always going to be the priority. But it does feel like a really valuable public service I can do. I don't want people out and about you know that don't really know very much about bees to have a negative bee interaction. just because there was a bee in a valve box that they happen to run by a lot and then they get chased or stung. I mean bees are so important and I think they are generally quite harmless. There's just usually something unfortunately that, you know, can set them off.
35:41 Like maybe someone just ran their lawnmower a little too long by where they happen to be or just making too much noise or vibration or there was some smell or odor that just set them off. There's more research for you. Why do bees not like internal combustion engines? Alright, last thought, 30 seconds Genesis. Why do you love honeybees? Why do I love honeybees? Well, I don't know. I started working with ants and then I switched to honeybees and I just got in love with bees. They always teach me so many new things and they always surprise me too. I was a TA in the bees and beekeeping class. And it's really nice and rewarding to see the students when they start the class, the perception that they have about honeybees and then seeing their perspective by the end of the class and see the switch completely.
36:44 Maybe they start the class afraid of them and then they leave loving bees, respect them. It's kind of like as they lose that. Fear of the bees. So I don't know. I feel that's really cool and nice. That's great. All right, you two Thank you very much for your time and keep up the good work and all this research I can't wait to see where it goes next and In I'm gonna say less than five years Genesis. This whole thing is gonna be solved Yeah, well feel free to check like the web page of the lab because There is people doing really cool stuff, like there is Sakshi, she's working with engineers and physics to try to figure out a way to quantify defensiveness on colonies with sensors. So there's like really cool stuff cooking around. Yeah. Thanks again for joining us on Be Love, Be Keeping presented by Manlike. Another big thank you goes to V2B Health for their support. Vita's Varroa Control Ranger products includes Epistan, Epigard, and now Varroxan Extended Release Oxalic Acid Strips.
38:01 Hey, thanks a lot guys. And if you haven't yet, please subscribe to and follow the show, tell your friends about it, and click on over to BeLoveBekeeping .com to sign up for our free newsletter. If you have a guest suggestion or topic you'd like discussed on the show, shoot me an email, eric at BeLoveBekeeping .com and remember if you're not just in it for the honey or the money, you're in it for the love. See you next week.
RSS Feed